To cook the perfect steak, bring it to room temperature, pat it dry, season it with salt and cook it in a very hot, heavy pan. For a steak two centimetres thick, allow two minutes each side for rare, three for medium and four to five for well done, then rest it for five minutes. The method is the same whichever cut you choose.
Step by step method
- Take it out early. Remove the steak from the fridge thirty minutes before cooking. A cold steak cooks unevenly.
- Dry it. Pat both sides with kitchen paper. A dry surface browns, and a wet one steams.
- Season it. Salt both sides generously just before cooking. Add pepper afterwards, because it burns in a hot pan.
- Heat the pan. Use a heavy frying pan or griddle and heat it until it is very hot. Add a little oil with a high smoke point.
- Cook it and leave it alone. Lay the steak in the pan away from you and do not move it until it is time to turn it.
- Add butter. In the last minute, add a knob of butter, a crushed garlic clove and a sprig of thyme, and spoon the butter over the steak.
- Rest it. Lift it onto a warm plate and leave it for five minutes.
How long do I cook a steak?
For a steak about two centimetres thick:
- Rare - two minutes each side. The centre reads about 50C.
- Medium rare - two and a half minutes each side, about 55C.
- Medium - three minutes each side, about 60C.
- Well done - four to five minutes each side, about 70C.
A thicker steak needs longer. For a thick fillet or a T-bone, brown it in the pan and finish it in a hot oven for a few minutes.
Which steak should I choose?
- sirloin - a balance of tenderness and flavour, with a strip of fat along one edge.
- rib eye - the most marbling, which makes it the richest. Best cooked medium rare to medium.
- rump - firmer, with a deep beef flavour and the best value.
- fillet - the most tender and the leanest. Best rare to medium.
- T-bone - sirloin and fillet on one bone.
All of these are dry aged for 28 days or more. Our article on dry-aged beef explains why that matters.
Why do I need to rest a steak?
During cooking, the juices are driven towards the centre of the meat. Resting lets them spread back through the steak, so they stay in the meat when you cut it. A steak that is cut straight from the pan loses its juices onto the plate.
What are the most common mistakes?
- A pan that is not hot enough, which gives a grey steak with no crust.
- Too many steaks in the pan at once, which cools it down.
- Turning or pressing the steak too often.
- Skipping the rest.
What should I serve with it?
Chips, a grilled tomato and mushrooms are the classic choice. A pepper sauce or steak ketchup from Fresh and Deli finishes it off. See all our beef steaks. Reilly's Butchers is at 74 Longridge Road, Ribbleton, Preston PR2 6RJ. Call 01772 791883 or get in touch if you have a question about an order.
Frequently asked questions
How long do you cook a steak for medium rare?
About two and a half minutes each side in a very hot pan for a steak two centimetres thick, followed by five minutes of resting.
Should I oil the steak or the pan?
Either works. A little oil in a very hot pan is the simplest method. Use an oil with a high smoke point, not butter, which burns. Add butter only in the last minute.
How long should a steak rest?
About five minutes for a steak, on a warm plate.
Which steak is best for pan frying?
Sirloin, rib eye, rump and fillet all suit pan frying. Rib eye is the richest and fillet the most tender.